I want to start with a confession that took me a long time to make out loud, because it is the reason I can write this at all.
For about six years I prayed a prayer every time I had a decision, and I believed it was a prayer for guidance, and it was not. It was a prayer for a signature.
The tell is the timing. I prayed it after I had decided. Every single time. I would work the thing through, arrive at an answer, and then bring it to God and ask Him to confirm it, and when nothing came back I would take the silence as agreement and proceed.
That is not asking. That is presenting a document and waiting for an objection.
And I was not being cynical. I would have told you, sincerely, that I was seeking God's will. The language was right. The vocabulary was right. And the position of my heart was that of a person who had finished thinking and wanted a countersignature.
What James is quoting
James does something in the fourth chapter that teachers rarely do. He quotes the sentence he is correcting, and it sounds entirely ordinary.
Go to now, ye that say, To day or to morrow we will go into such a city, and continue there a year, and buy and sell, and get gain. (James 4:13, King James Version)
Read that carefully. There is nothing wrong with any of it. A city, a year, a trade. It is a sensible business plan and there is no sin named in the sentence.
What he objects to is not the planning. It is the certainty about a future nobody owns. He says as much in the next verse, about a vapor that appears for a little time.
And then he gives the correction, and it is four words long.
For that ye ought to say, If the Lord will, we shall live, and do this, or that. (James 4:15)
If the Lord will. Notice what survives the correction. We shall live, and do this, or that is still in the sentence. The plan is not deleted. The plan is placed under something.
You are permitted to plan, and James corrects the certainty rather than the planning, and James 4 leaves the itinerary standing and puts four words in front of it. The same Spirit is the one who makes those four words a genuine posture instead of a formula tacked on.
Guidance and permission are different requests
Here is the distinction I could not see for six years, and it is worth being precise about, because the words look identical.
A request for permission has one acceptable answer and the person making it already knows what it is. It is closed. The purpose of it is to remove risk from a decision already made, by transferring responsibility.
A request for guidance is open. It has more than one possible outcome that the person asking is genuinely willing to receive.
That last clause is the whole test, and it is not a test of sincerity. It is a test of what would happen if the answer were no.
You are able to ask an open question, and the ability is not a matter of spiritual maturity, it is a matter of what you are actually willing to hear (James 4:15), and it is the Spirit who opens a hand that has closed around an outcome without the person noticing.
And Proverbs names the situation with no sentiment at all.
There are many devices in a man's heart; nevertheless the counsel of the LORD, that shall stand. (Proverbs 19:21)
Many devices. That is the planning, and it is not condemned. And then the counsel of the LORD stands, which is a statement about outcomes rather than about anybody's failure.
What this is not
I need to put a fence around this before it does damage, because in the wrong hands it becomes a rod.
This is not a teaching that says your plans are presumptuous. James does not say that and neither do I. Planning is competence, and competence is not a rival to faith.
It is also not a teaching that God is offended by a person who prays late. He is not standing on the correct order of operations. A person who has been praying for a signature for six years, as I was, has not been out of fellowship for six years.
And it is not a method. Saying four words does not change the outcome of a decision, and treating them as a lever is exactly the formula this site refuses to sell.
You have not been out of favor for a single one of those years, and God never made the sequence of your praying the condition of His attention (Proverbs 19:21), and the Spirit is the one who has been at work in the plans a person made before they thought to ask about them.
What the four words do is not transactional. They change the person saying them.
The prayer that models it
The clearest example of an open request in Scripture is short, and it comes from the hardest night anybody has ever had.
Saying, Father, if thou be willing, remove this cup from me: nevertheless not my will, but thine, be done. (Luke 22:42)
Both halves are in it. He asks for something specific, plainly, without hedging. And then He places it under.
That is the shape. Not a vague prayer that asks for nothing so it cannot be disappointed. A definite request, genuinely made, held under a will that is not the one making it.
You are allowed to want the thing and to say so plainly, and the model prayer for this asks for a specific outcome before it yields it (Luke 22:42). The Spirit is the one who makes the second half of that sentence something a person means rather than recites.
So say the plan out loud, and then say the four words, and mean them.
You have been given permission to plan and a place to put the plan, and both of those are in the same sentence in James (James 4:15), and the Holy Spirit is the one who turns four words from a disclaimer into a posture.
Now the counterfeit, and it is severe on conscientious people, so learn its shape. It says: six years of your praying were manipulation, you have been using God as a rubber stamp. That is vague, it names you rather than an act, and its only instruction is shame. Conviction from the Holy Spirit names one specific thing and always opens a door in the same breath, and the door here is four words in a kitchen.
You are not a manipulator, and a person can pray sincerely in the wrong order for years without one moment of dishonesty in it (Psalm 139:23), and that part belongs to the Holy Spirit, who shows a thing like this at the exact point a person is able to hear it and not before.
This does not promise the plan changes or that the answer arrives. The man in my class kept his plan and never got a word about it. What is settled is that planning is not presumption, that four words are a posture rather than a lever, and that the asking is where the change happens.
Declare this over yourself
Say these out loud. Christ is in you, and the right to speak over your own praying came with Him rather than being manufactured. God left the plan standing in James and put four words in front of it, so speak to the countersignature you have been asking Him for. Say what is written, and then let it stand in His timing rather than yours.
- Signature I have been asking Him for, you are not prayer and you are not what I actually need. The Word of God says that ye ought to say, if the Lord will, we shall live and do this or that, and the plan is still in the sentence.
- Shame about the order I have been praying in, you are finished in the name of Jesus. Scripture says there are many devices in a man's heart and the counsel of the LORD shall stand, and it never called the devices a sin.
- Father, Luke 22:42 asks plainly for a specific thing and then says nevertheless not my will but Thine. I say the plan out loud tonight and put it under You, and I thank You that Your Spirit makes those four words a posture and not a formula.
James 4:15
This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.